SOC logo and home page link
Society of Camera Operators
SOC logo imageNew on SOC.orgContact the SOCAbout the SOCMagazine
Membership in the SOC
Operating Cameraman magazine
SOC Events and Seminars
SOC Bookstore
Related links
Bottom cap image

2 Be or Not 2 Be
A "Star Wars" Memory
By David Robman, SOC

From the July/December 1997 issue of the Operating Cameraman

Star destroyer thumbnail
David Robman thumbnail
Click thumbnails for larger view

The sun was shining on that winter's day in late 1976, but inside the black-draped stage in a warehouse in Van Nuys, things weren't so bright. A pall had been cast over the heads of myself and the other David. But since it's always better to start at the beginning, I will.

In October of 1976, I found myself leaving a job as a messenger boy from Kaleidoscope Films in Hollywood to become a camera assistant for the visual effects unit on an unheard-of film called "Star Wars." Industrial Light and Magic had been formed about a year earlier to put together this film that almost every studio had passed on before 20th Century Fox said yes. Through a connection, I landed the job because I had been to film school and I knew my way around a camera. Little did they know that I didn't know Blue Screen from Blue Cross, but I wasn't going to pass up this opportunity.

I got lucky. I was put together with Dennis Muren and Ken Ralston to help photograph spaceships. Two of the nicest and most helpful guys you ever want to meet. They have since won over a dozen academy awards, but even then I knew I was in good company.

On my first day, I asked Ken if there was a shooting script I could read. He replied there was only one script in the entire building and it was kept under wraps due to its unique nature. I understood the importance of the secrecy, but I still wanted to know what the movie was all about.

He replied: "Oh, that's easy. You see, there's these two droids, R2D2 and C3PO, on this rebel ship. And during an attack, they get in a pod to escape Darth Vader and jettison themselves into space. But instead of landing on the 4th moon of Yavin, they end up on the planet Tatooine, where they're captured by Jawas in their Sandcrawler. And then…"

"Wait!" I said. "What the heck are you talking about?" I realized at that moment this was to be a very different kind of movie, and no verbal synopsis would take the place of seeing the finished product in the theater. I knew then why all the studios had said no to this undertaking, but what I was still wondering was why 20th had said yes. Someone must have had a crystal ball! I thanked Ken for trying and we proceeded to the work at hand.

A few weeks later, another assistant, Dave Berry (DaveB), and I were asked to split off from Dennis and Ken in order to shoot painted glass planets and starfield footage. We leaped at the chance and dove right in.

It was during a planet session that our story unfolds. As many of these shots were only a few seconds in length, our shots were measured in frames. For whatever reason, our slates were just pieces of notebook paper with shot #, date, take #, etc. written in large felt-tip marker. We'd fill out the slate, stick it up on the painted glass and run off a few frames.

On this fateful day, DaveB and I were busy with the day's work. As can be the case, one of us had inadvertently neglected to change the take # on a slate we were about to shoot. "Hold it!" I said. "Let me change it." I took the marker and walked over to the paper stuck up on the glass. I carefully changed the ‘one' to a ‘two' and we shot the slate. I walked over to the slate and pulled it off the glass and there in the middle of the beautifully painted planet of Tatooine was a two-inch black-inked '2'!!!

Godfrey-Daniel, Jolly-Roger, Doctor Bee-Bee!! (W. C. Fields… I couldn't resist.) DaveB and I just looked at each other. Both hoping we could quickly solve this thing like Butch and Sundance did off that 200' cliff.

But, alas, this one started to look like Lucy and Ethel in the chocolate factory. Imagine our horror. It was one of those moments in life where you must decide how significant a mistake just made really is.

Instantly, we knew this was not an "Oh gosh, I just burnt the toast. What a shame... I'll just put another piece in the toaster" type of mistake. This was an "I'm standing at the altar and I forgot to bring the wedding ring" type of mistake.

We obviously didn't remember that felt tip markers bleed through paper. And boy, did it bleed through this time… like it was brand new! I had just ruined a $5,000 painting. I immediately went to the phone and called the airlines to see when the soonest flight was to the farthest destination from Van Nuys. I figured if I could get to Siberia before anyone saw the goof, I could still live a happy life.

But calmer heads prevailed and DaveB and I soon realized our true course of action… blame it on the dog!

Seriously, even though we were quaking in our boots, we kept our heads and realized that removing the offending ‘2' before it dried was of paramount importance. As you might have experienced, a felt tip marker only stays wet when you accidentally rub it against your new pants or your clean white shirt.

This ‘2' wasn't going anywhere with Kleenex dabs. We decided to get the storyboard artist (Joe Johnston, later to direct "Honey I Shrunk the Kids" and "Jumanji") who was the lone person in the building with an art background to see if he could do something about removing the offending ‘2'. We swore Joe to secrecy because rather than tell too many people, DaveB and I chose to alert as few as necessary until that moment when the guillotine was the only option left.

Joe perused the painting. He could have easily buried us but that wasn't the ILM style. This was truly a great group of people who, when problems arose, would jump in and fix whatever needed to be fixed for the good of the show.

I saw it happen with mistakes such as ours, equipment breakdowns, and the sheer tenacity from every department to get the best possible footage on every shot asked of us. That's probably why the movie turned out the way it did. Joe was no different. He proceeded to apply solvent to the ink and carefully remove it from the painting.

It was amazing. Joe was able to remove the black ink with only the smallest amount of the planet's orange coloring coming off. DaveB and I felt our breathing start to come back to normal.

Joe proceeded to take the paint that had been slopped over onto the frame (by the original artist) and add it to the area where the ‘2' had been. The planet returned to normal. The job was complete. But DaveB and I still knew where the ‘2' had been, so Joe's work wasn't the final test. Call in the boss.

John Dykstra was the visual effects supervisor. We decided to call him in, not tell him why, and ask him to view the painting close-up to see if he could find anything wrong.

He sat down in front of the painting, not more than a foot away, and stared at the planet. After a few moments, he declared: "I don't see any problems." I called the airlines and canceled my flight. We thanked him and sent him back to his office. I'm not sure if we ever told him why he was asked to stare at the painting.

DaveB and I finished shooting take ‘2' and went on to the next shot. We tied the marker to a string and made sure it couldn't go more than two feet from our work bench. One close shave was all we needed. The pall had disappeared. The sun even seemed to shine on our darkened stage. But that ‘2' was emblazoned on my mind from that day on. So, when you see the opening shot in Star Wars, and the planet comes into view, you won't see a ‘2'... but I do!